Pragmatic Case Studies in Psychotherapy


*** About PCSP: click on ABOUT button above and look in Policies.

*** Instructions for Authors and Author Guidelines: click on ABOUT buttom above and look in Submissions.   

*** For best viewing of this web site, use Internet Explorer, Chrome, Firefox, or Safari.
To open the pdf files requires Acrobat version 8.0 or higher (see below). 

April 22, 2017 -- From the Editor 

ANNOUNCING THE PUBLICATION OF OUR 48th ISSUE (Vol. 13, Module 1)

The Case of "Hiro": Treating Tourette Syndrome by Comprehensive Behavioral Intervention for Tics (CBIT)  

*** Jeremy Lichtman, Tourette Syndrome Clinic, Rutgers University-New Brunswick, Piscataway, NJ 

Commentaries  

***  Matthew Capriotti, San Jose State University, San Jose, CA  

*** Brianna Wellen & Michael Himle, University of Utah, Salt Lake city, UT  

*** Daniela Colognori & Lori Rockmore, Tourette Syndrome Clinic, Rutgers University-New Brunswick, Piscataway, NJ

Response to Commentaries 

*** Jeremy Lichtman, Tourette Syndrome Clinic, Rutgers University-New Brunswick, Piscataway, NJ    

For Table of Contents and access to articles: go to bottom of this page; or click on "Current" button at top of this page. 

EDITOR'S NOTE:

Hiro, a 10-year old south Asian boy, presented with Tourette Syndrome, specifically with multiple motor and vocal tics, including simple motor tics such as head jerking and eye blinking; and simple vocal tics, such as sniffing and grunting. In addition, Hiro manifested obsessive thoughts, compulsive behaviors, and symptoms of Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD).

A logical treatment choice for Hiro was Comprehensive Behavioral Interaction for Tics (CBIT), an empirically supported, protocol-based treatment manual derived from cognitive-behavioral therapy principles. In implementing this treatment, the therapist--Dr. Jeremy Lichtman--found that in a number of ways, Hiro responded very well to the manual.

However, in other ways, Lichtman found Hiro to be unresponsive, and—with guidance from his supervisor—he thus decided to add to or deviate from the manual to better tailor the treatment to Hiro’s individualized needs.  For example, (a) Lichtman determined he needed 19 sessions for the treatment instead of the 8 called for by the manual; (b) he added a crucial component of developing parental buy-in, which was not in the manual; (c) he had to call upon his creativity to add to the limited number of competing responses provided in the manual to meet Hiro's needs; (d) he needed to add to the manual to deal with a number of Hiro's particularly challenging tics, like grunting; and (e) he had to go beyond the manual to address Hiro's ADHD. In addition, Lichtman de-emphasized certain elements called for in the manual--like Function-Based Assessment--because he found that they were "unnecessary and proved wieldy."

Overall, Hiro's treatment was quite successful both quantitatively and qualitatively. Therefore, a general question emerging from the case and considered by the three sets of commentators is whether the flexibility and creativity Lichtman used in deviating from the CBIT manual--and the rationales for these deviations--were justified. First, Matthew Capriotti finds them justified by preferring a "Principles First" versus a "Protocol First" approach to treatment. In a parallel way, Brianna Wellen and Michael Himle also find them justified by preferring the model of a "Culinarian," who is trained "in the art and science of preparing, cooking, and presenting food" to that of a "Cook," who is trained to strictly follow recipes. Finally, Daniela Colognori and Lori Rockmore take a different position by noting that when Lichtman conducted Hiro's case, Lichtman was a relatively beginning therapist, and perhaps he made some novice errors and should have followed CBIT manual more closely.

In responding to the commentaries, Lichtman advocates for the importance of balancing the arguments for a "mechanical/algorithmic" versus a "flexible/creative" approach in applying a therapy manual. To accomplish this balancing he emphasizes that an understanding of the principles underlying the manual is the best way to bridge the two approaches.  

PCSP is Abstracted in:

** PsycINFO (APA)

** Academic Search Complete (EBSCO) 

Conceptual Overview

A conceptual overview of the journal is available by going to the About PCSP link found by clicking on the ABOUT link above and looking under Policies.  

Access to Current Articles

The current article series or "Module" is available on the right side of this home page. As shown, articles are available in HTML format for the Abstract and bibliographic information, and in PDF format for full text. This format requires the following plug-in: Acrobat Plug-in (use version 8.0 or above)

Editorial Board

** View. View by clicking on the EDITORIAL BOARD link at the top of the page. Along with their names and affiliations, samples of the Editorial Board members' scholarly, clinical, and research accomplishments are briefly summarized.

Call for Papers

** Manuscripts. Two types of manuscripts are desired: those consisting of one or more case studies, and those consisting of case method articles.

** Suggested Author Guidelines. These can be found by clicking on the link Instructions for Authors, as described above. Note that we suggest 11 common headings for case study manuscripts:
1. Case Context and Method
2. The Client
3. Guiding Conception with Research and Clinical Experience Support
4. Assessment of the Client's Problems, Goals, Strengths, and History.
5. Formulation and Treatment Plan
6. Course of Therapy
7. Therapy Monitoring and Use of Feedback Information
8. Concluding Evaluation of the Therapy's Process and Outcome
9. References
10. Tables (optional)
11. Figures (optional)
Also note that on the Instructions for Authors page,  there are substantive guidelines within each heading. However, these should be viewed as suggestions only, not as requirements.

** Author Policies.For author policies about manuscript submission, copyright, and confidentiality, click on the link Authors Guidelines, as described above. 

** Format. In the initial phase of the journal, manuscripts should be submitted if possible as Word documents using the manuscript style guidelines of the American Psychological Association.

** Submitting Manuscripts. During the initial phase of the journal, authors should submit manuscripts by emailing a Word file to the Editor, Daniel Fishman, at DFish96198@aol.com.

** Note: the PCSP web site has an automated method for submitting manuscripts, which will be activated after the initial phase of the journal.

** Questions. Any questions about manuscript ideas or formats should be addressed to the Editor at DFish96198@aol.com.

Searching

Current and past articles can be searched for full-text or otherwise by clicking on the link for SEARCH at the top of the page.     

PCSP Sponsors

PCSP is sponsored by the Rutgers Graduate School of Applied & Professional Psychology, and by the Rutgers University Libraries (RUL). To learn about the RUL's philosophy on open-access, online, peer-reviewed journal publishing, click on the ABOUT link at the top of the page, go to Policies, and then click on Open Access Policy.   

Contact

Contact. To get in touch with the PCSP Editor and webmaster, click on the the ABOUT link at the top of the page, go to People, and then click on Contact.   

Vol 13, No 1 (2017)

Table of Contents

Case Study

The Case of "Hiro": Treating Tourette Syndrome by Comprehensive Behavioral Intervention for Tics (CBIT) Abstract PDF
Jeremy D. Lichtman 1-37
On Protocols and Principles in the Case of Hiro Abstract PDF
Matthew R. Capriotti 38-50
From Cook to Culinarian: Going Beyond the Manual When Delivering Behavior Therapy to Treat Tourette Disorder Abstract PDF
Brianna Wellen, Michael B. Himle 51-62
Perspectives on Training Clinicians to Effectively Implement Evidence-based Treatment for Tourette Syndrome Abstract PDF
Daniela Colognori, Lori Rockmore 63-72
Mechanical/Algorithmic Versus Flexible/Creative Clinical Practice: How Underlying Principles Bridge the Gap Abstract PDF
Jeremy D. Lichtman 73-81